| 
Author
 | 
Comment
 | 
rosyelf 
 Registered User  
(12/15/04 12:37 pm) 
  
  
 | 
 Two fantasy novels based on Arthurian mythos 
  
   I have come across 2 interesting-looking novels on Amazon and wonder if anyone here has read them ? The first is I AM MORGAN LE FAY by Nancy Springer-N.S. is mentioned in another current thread here-and the second is ISOLDE, QUEEN OF THE WESTERN ISLES by Rosalind Miles. The second book is the first of a trilogy. I am not looking for a slavish retelling of the original Arthurian tales, but I am looking for an authentic FEEL to the books. 
 
    Can anyone help ? 
 
      love 
 
          rosyelf 
 | 
aka Greensleeves 
 Registered User  
(12/15/04 8:00 pm) 
  
  
 | 
 Re: Two fantasy novels based on Arthurian mythos 
 Well, what's your definition of "authentic?"  NS's MORGAN is set in Roman Cornwall, and the landscape and atmosphere are very strong--almost characters.  I think her I AM MORDRED is better known, although I've only read MORGAN.  It is a middle-grade novel (kids), and it is about Morgan's childhood, so that's one thing to keep in mind. 
 | 
AliceCEB 
 Registered User  
(12/16/04 8:14 am) 
  
  
 | 
 Re: Two fantasy novels based on Arthurian mythos 
 Rosyelf, I haven't read either book.  But a version I've liked is Marion Zimmer Bradley's Mists of Avalon told from the point of view of the women in the legend. 
 
Best, 
Alice 
 | 
Laura McCaffrey 
 Registered User  
(12/16/04 8:20 am) 
  
  
 | 
 Re: Two fantasy novels based on Arthurian mythos 
 Nancy Springer's are a psychological exploration of character.  By this I mean that she explores what it would be to be the bad mistrusted son in I AM MORDRED, or the girl, Morgan, whose father was killed by Arthur's father. 
 
I haven't read the other book. 
 
LauraMc 
 | 
rosyelf 
 Registered User  
(12/17/04 7:20 am) 
  
  
 | 
 fantasy novels 
  
 
   Thank you, all, for your responses. Greensleeves, when I say "authentic" I suppose I mean the sort of thing you mention-brooding landscape that is almost a character in itself, a sense that the author has plunged deeply into the place and time of the story. 
 
              As for Morgan le Fay, obviously my reading level is above middle 
              grade (at least, I hope so-I'm 38) , but the CHILDHOOD of Morgan 
              sounds absolutely fascinating. I'm also keen on following up the 
              Mordred book, for similar reasons. 
 
 THE MISTS OF AVALON is a book I love, especially the way it delves deep into the lives of the Arthurian women. 
 |